An independent reference. Not affiliated with any government agency, professional society, or manufacturer.

The Integrative Psychiatry
Evidence Project

A cited reference for the definition, scope, and evidence base of integrative psychiatry.

Definition › vs. integrative psychotherapy

Integrative psychiatry and integrative psychotherapy

Three fields share a word. Separating them.

In short

Integrative psychotherapy combines theoretical orientations within psychotherapy. Integrative psychiatry is medical practice by a physician who can prescribe. Integrated care is a service-delivery model that puts mental health treatment inside primary care. The three share an adjective and very little else.

Why these get confused

The confusion is visible in search behaviour. Across a recent 90-day window, queries for “integrative psychology,” “integrative therapy,” “holistic psychotherapy,” and “integrated psychiatry” together drew roughly as much traffic as queries for integrative psychiatry itself. People arrive at one of these terms looking for another.

There is a structural reason. General-purpose encyclopedias carry an article on integrative psychotherapy and none on integrative psychiatry, so a search engine asked about the second frequently returns the first. The absence is doing the substituting.

Side by side

Integrative psychotherapyIntegrative psychiatryIntegrated care
What it is An approach within psychotherapy that draws on more than one theoretical orientation. Medical practice applying the full available assessment and treatment set, with functioning and quality of life as the outcomes. A service-delivery model placing mental health treatment inside primary care.
Who practises it Psychologists, clinical social workers, licensed counsellors, and psychiatrists. Physicians. Psychiatrists, and in some settings other prescribers. A team: primary care clinician, care manager, consulting psychiatrist.
Prescribing Generally not. A small number of US states permit specifically trained psychologists to prescribe under defined conditions. Yes. Prescribing is central to the work. Yes, through the primary care clinician with psychiatric consultation.
What gets combined Theoretical orientations: psychodynamic, cognitive behavioural, humanistic, systemic. Treatment methods: medication, psychotherapy, sleep, exercise, diet, mind-body practice. Professions and settings, rather than methods.
Evidence status An established field with its own APA journal since 1991.1 The label is unregulated; individual methods vary widely in support. See the grading framework. Strong. Randomised trials and systematic reviews.34

What integrative psychotherapy actually is

Psychotherapy integration is a recognised field with a history, a professional literature, and an American Psychological Association journal published since 1991.1 Its subject is how a therapist can combine orientations that were developed separately, and the debate within it concerns how much of psychotherapy’s effect comes from factors common to all approaches against ingredients specific to each.2

The word “integrative” here refers to combining theories of how people change. It carries no implication about nutrition, supplements, sleep, or laboratory testing.

What integrative psychiatry is

Integrative psychiatry is the practice of psychiatry in which the full range of available assessment and treatment methods is applied to a case, and in which the patient’s functioning and quality of life serve as the primary outcomes.5 The full definition sets out its four clauses.

The word “integrative” here refers to combining treatment methods, and the practitioner is a physician. Unlike psychotherapy integration, the term has no professional body, no journal of its own, and no board certification. That difference matters when judging a claim: one of these fields has infrastructure behind its label and the other does not.

Integrated care is a third thing entirely

“Integrated psychiatry” and “integrated behavioural health” usually refer to the collaborative care model, in which mental health treatment is delivered inside primary care with a care manager and a consulting psychiatrist. A randomised trial in late-life depression established its effect,3 and a systematic review across depression and anxiety confirmed it.4

This is among the better-supported service innovations in the field. It has nothing to do with integrative psychiatry, and the similarity of the names does the evidence a disservice in both directions.

Which one does a given problem call for?

If the question isThe relevant field is
Whether to start, change, or stop a psychiatric medication Psychiatry. A prescriber is required.
Whether a therapist will use more than one method with you Integrative psychotherapy. Ask which orientations, and for what.
Whether sleep, exercise, and diet will be treated as clinical targets alongside medication Integrative psychiatry as defined here.
Getting mental health treatment through a primary care practice Integrated or collaborative care.
Diagnostic uncertainty about what is actually going on Psychiatry, for the differential. Assessment precedes method selection.
  • Integrative psychology. Not a recognised discipline or licence. The phrase appears mostly in practice names. Someone searching it usually wants either psychotherapy integration or a psychiatrist.
  • Holistic psychotherapy. Used interchangeably with integrative psychotherapy in marketing, with no separate professional meaning. See holistic and naturopathic practice.
  • Eclectic therapy. An older term for selecting techniques by what the individual patient needs. Psychotherapy integration is the more systematic descendant of it.

References

  1. Journal of Psychotherapy Integration. American Psychological Association. ISSN 1053-0479 (print), 1573-3696 (online). Published since 1991.
  2. Wampold BE, Ulvenes PG. Integration of common factors and specific ingredients. In: Handbook of Psychotherapy Integration. Oxford University Press; 2019:69–87. doi:10.1093/med-psych/9780190690465.003.0003
  3. Unützer J, Katon W, Callahan CM, et al. Collaborative care management of late-life depression in the primary care setting: a randomized controlled trial. JAMA. 2002;288(22):2836–2845. PMID 12472325. doi:10.1001/jama.288.22.2836
  4. Archer J, Bower P, Gilbody S, et al. Collaborative care for depression and anxiety problems. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2012;10:CD006525. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD006525.pub2
  5. Varteresian T, Lavretsky H. Complementary and integrative therapies in psychiatry. FOCUS (Am Psychiatr Publ). 2018;16(1):54–56. PMID 31975900. doi:10.1176/appi.focus.20170056